Rebuttals to Articles

Detailed rebuttals to the so called “Errors” in the Noble Quran:

Source: www.answering-christianity.com

Internal contradictions claims and responses:

  1. Anti-Islamic claim:  Who suffers loss if Muhammad was wrong?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  2. Anti-Islamic claim:  Allah, Adam, and the Angels.
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  3. Anti-Islamic claim:  Who Was the First Muslim?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Sami Zaatari.
  4. Anti-Islamic claim:   Can Allah be seen and did Muhammad see his Lord?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Bassam Zawadi.
  5. Anti-Islamic claim:  Were Warners Sent to All Mankind Before Muhammad?
    Islamic Responses:
    My response (1)
    My response (2)
  6. Anti-Islamic claim:  What will be the food for the people in Hell?
    Islamic Responses:   My response
  7. Anti-Islamic claim:  Can Angels Cause the Death of People?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Sami Zaatari.
  8. Anti-Islamic claim:  Confusion Concerning Identity of the Spirit and Gabriel
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  9. Anti-Islamic claim:  ‘Iddah rules for divorced and widowed women
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  10. Anti-Islamic claim:  Is there a minimum age of marriage for girls?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Adeel Khan.
  11. Anti-Islamic claim:  To Marry or Not to Marry?
    Islamic Responses:
    Response by Karim. (1)
    Response by Karim. (2)
  12. Anti-Islamic claim:  Will it be accepted of them or not?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Mucahit Sivri.
  13. Anti-Islamic claim:  Will Allah reward the good deeds of Unbelievers?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Bassam Zawadi.
  14. Anti-Islamic claim:  Should Muslims Accept Peace or Not?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Adeel Khan.
  15. Anti-Islamic claim:  Can They Disbelieve in the Last Day and be Safe?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Adeel Khan.
  16. Anti-Islamic claim:  Should Muslims show kindness to their parents?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Yahya Ahmed.
  17. Anti-Islamic claim:  Can one be a believer in God and oppose Muhammad at the same time?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Yahya Ahmed.
  18. Anti-Islamic claim:  How many mothers does a Muslim have?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Karim.
  19. Anti-Islamic claim:  And it just doesn’t add up.
    Islamic Responses: A new response by the Learner
    Understanding The Law of Inheritance of the Qur’an (by the Learner)
    Response by a Muslim
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Khalid
    Response by Randy Desmond
    My response
  20. Anti-Islamic claim:  How many angels were talking to Mary?
    Islamic Responses: My response
    The Learner’s response
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
    Response by Khalid
  21. Anti-Islamic claim:  Further numerical discrepancies.
    Islamic Responses: My response
    Response by Karim
    Gardens or Gardens?
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  22. Anti-Islamic claim:  How many days did Allah need to destroy the people of Aad?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  23. Anti-Islamic claim:  Six or eight days of creation?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Dr. Zakir Naik.
    My response
    Response by Karim (pdf file)
    Response by MENJ
    Six or Eight Days of Creation?
    The Length of God’s Days   A Numerical Discrepancy?
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  24. Anti-Islamic claim:  Quick or slow creation?
    Islamic Responses: Quick or Slow Creation?
    The Meanings of “Thumma” and “Yawm”
    Response by Neil Littlejohn (Ismail)
  25. Anti-Islamic claim:  Which was created first, Heavens or Earth?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
    Response by Frank
  26. Anti-Islamic claim:  Calling together or ripping apart?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  27. Anti-Islamic claim:  What was man created from?
    Islamic Responses: What was Man Created From?
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  28. Anti-Islamic claim:  Fully Detailed Or Incomplete?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  29. Anti-Islamic claim:  Worshiping the Same or a Different God?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by MENJ
  30. Anti-Islamic claim:  To Intercede or Not To Intercede? – That is the Question!
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  31. Anti-Islamic claim:  Where is Allah and his throne?
    Islamic Responses: Where is Allah and his throne?
  32. Anti-Islamic claim:  The origin of calamity?
    Islamic Responses:
     Is Evil from Satan, Ourselves or Allah?
    My response.
  33. Anti-Islamic claim:  How merciful is Allah’s mercy?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
    Response by Understanding Islam
    Response by the Learner
  34. Anti-Islamic claim:  Does Allah command to do evil?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Karim
  35. Anti-Islamic claim:  Should Muhammad Get Paid Or Shouldn’t He?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Adeel Khan.
  36. Anti-Islamic claim:  Will there be inquiry in Paradise?
    Islamic Responses: Inquiry in Paradise
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  37. Anti-Islamic claim:  Are angels Protectors?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  38. Anti-Islamic claim:  Is Allah the only Wali?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Adeel Khan.
  39. Anti-Islamic claim:  Is everything devoutly obedient to Allah?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  40. Anti-Islamic claim:  Does Allah forgive shirk (believing in more than one God)?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
    Response by the Learner (1)
    Response by the Learner (2)
    Response by the Learner (3)
  41. Anti-Islamic claim:  The event of worship of the golden calf.
    Islamic Responses:  Response by MENJResponse by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
    Response by the Learner (1)
    Response by the Learner (2)
  42. Anti-Islamic claim:  Was Jonah cast on the desert shore or was he not?
    Islamic Responses: My responseResponse by the Learner
  43. Anti-Islamic claim:  Moses and the Injil (New Testament)?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  44. Anti-Islamic claim:  Can slander of chaste women be forgiven?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by MENJ
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Amiri-Shirifi
  45. Anti-Islamic claim:  How do we receive the record on judgment day?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  46. Anti-Islamic claim:  Can Angels disobey Allah?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by MENJ
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Shaahin Sharifi
  47. Anti-Islamic claim:  Is Satan an angel or a jinn?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Adeel Khan.
  48. Anti-Islamic claim:  Three contradictions in 2:97 and 16:101-103.
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Shaahin Amiri-Sharifi
  49. Anti-Islamic claim:  Do not say, “Three”!?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Adeel Khan.
  50. Anti-Islamic claim:  The infinite loop problem.
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  51. Anti-Islamic claim:  Is the Torah like the Qur’an, or is it not?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  52. Anti-Islamic claim:  Should Jews and Christians follow the Bible or the Quran?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Adeel Khan.
  53. Anti-Islamic claim:  “An old woman” and God’s character.
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  54. Anti-Islamic claim:  More problems with the story of Lot.
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    Response by Randy Desmond
  55. Anti-Islamic claim:  The “pleasure” of Allah.
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  56. Anti-Islamic claim:  Did Abraham smash the idols?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  57. Anti-Islamic claim:  What about Noah’s son?
    Islamic Responses: My response
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  58. Anti-Islamic claim:  Was Noah driven out?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  59. Anti-Islamic claim:  Pharaoh’s Magicians: Muslims or Rejectors of Faith?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
    Also see my my response to their so-called “detailed” article that they linked at the bottom of the above article.
    Response by Bassam Zawadi
  60. Anti-Islamic claim:  Pharaoh’s repentance in the face of death?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  61. Anti-Islamic claim:  Abrogation?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  62. Anti-Islamic claim:  Guiding to truth?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  63. Anti-Islamic claim:  What is the punishment for adultery?
    Islamic Responses: My response
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  64. Anti-Islamic claim:  Who suffers the consequence of sins?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Karim
    Response by MENJ
  65. Anti-Islamic claim:  Will Christians enter Paradise or go to Hell?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  66. Anti-Islamic claim:  God alone or also men? Clear or incomprehensible?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  67. Anti-Islamic claim:  Was Pharaoh Drowned or Saved when chasing Moses and the Israelites?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by MENJ
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  68. Anti-Islamic claim:  When Commanded Pharaoh the Killing of the Sons?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  69. Anti-Islamic claim:  When/how are the fates determined?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  70. Anti-Islamic claim:  Wine: Good or bad?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by MENJ
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
    The Authenticity of the Quran.  By Minister Badawi.
  71. Anti-Islamic claim:  Good News of Painful Torture?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  72. Anti-Islamic claim:  Jinns and men created for worship or for Hell?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  73. Anti-Islamic claim:  Will all Muslims go to Hell?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  74. Anti-Islamic claim:  Will Allah disgrace Muslims?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Karim.
    Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  75. Anti-Islamic claim:  Will Jesus burn in Hell?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    My response
  76. Anti-Islamic claim:  Is Jesus God or Not?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Sami Zaatari.
  77. Anti-Islamic claim:  Can there be a son without a consort?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  78. Anti-Islamic claim:  Who is the father of Jesus?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Misha’al ibn Abdullah
  79. Anti-Islamic claim:  Begetting and Self-sufficiency.
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  80. Anti-Islamic claim:  Could Allah have a son?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  81. Anti-Islamic claim:  Did Jesus die already?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  82. Anti-Islamic claim:  One Creator or many?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  83. Anti-Islamic claim:  From among all nations or from Abraham’s seed?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  84. Anti-Islamic claim:  Marrying the wives of adopted sons?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  85. Anti-Islamic claim:  Messengers were never sent to other than their own people?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
    Response by Ahmed Eldin.
  86. Anti-Islamic claim:  Messengers Amongst the Jinns and Angels?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.Response by Sami Zaatari.
  87. Anti-Islamic claim:  Do all of God’s messengers eat food?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Adeel Khan.
  88. Anti-Islamic claim:  A Messenger from among the beasts?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Adeel Khan.
  89. Anti-Islamic claim:  Another eleven contradictions
    Islamic Responses:  (1)   My response
    (2)   My response
    (3)   My response
    (4)   My response
    (5)   My response
    (6)   My response
    (7)   The Learner’s response
    (8)   My response
    (9)   My response
    (10) My response
    (11) My response

Further:

Grammatical Errors

Anti-Islamic claim:  Contradictory Grammar.

Islamic Responses to “Answering Islam’s” and all of the other anti-Islamic sites’ claims: 

Anti-Islamic claim:  To speak or not to speak?

Islamic Responses: Response by Randy Desmond

External contradictions:

Anti-Islamic Introductory question

Response by Randy Desmond

  1. Anti-Islamic claim:  Solomon listening to ants?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Randy Desmond, a Muslim brother and me.
  2. Anti-Islamic claim:  The stars and the moon
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  3. Anti-Islamic claim:  Qur’an and Science: Section Four in Dr. Campbell’s book.
    Islamic Responses: Response by a Muslim
  4. Anti-Islamic claim:  Qur’an and Embryology
    Islamic Responses:My and others’ responses:

    1. The Noble Quran on Human Embryonic Development.
    2. Embryology in the Noble Quran.   The three stages of the fetus formation in the Noble Quran and Science.
    3. Abortion in Islam is a crime!   The fetus is a human child in Islam.
    4. The Noble Quran on the Cerebrum: Lying is generated from the person’s forehead.
    5. The region in the brain that controls our movements – In Noble Quran and confirmed by Science.
    6. Sex determination and human creation in Islam.  Allah Almighty and Prophet Muhammad both claimed that the human gender is determined by the male’s ejaculated semen.
    7. Rebuttal to Sam Shamoun on Semen Production in the Noble Quran.
    8. Were human cloning and gender alteration prophesied in Islam?
    9. Why does the Noble Quran, while speaking about determination of the identity of the individual, speak specifically about finger tips?   The Noble Quran recognized that finger tips (finger prints) are unique!
    10. The blood circulation and the production of milk in the Breast: In the Noble Quran and Science.
    11. Breastfeeding for 2 years in the Noble Quran.  Science had confirmed Islam’s Divine Claims.
    12. Thinking with the heart besides the brain in the Noble Quran was proven by Science.


    Response by Nadeem Arif Najmi

    It-is-truth answers

  5. Anti-Islamic claim:  Can non-living matter think, feel and have a will?
    Islamic Responses: My response
  6. Anti-Islamic claim: The human embryonic development
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Munir Munshey.
    My response
  7. Anti-Islamic claim:  The place of Sun rise and Sunset
    Islamic Responses: My responseResponse by Randy Desmond
    Debate: Jamal Badawi’s Response (Video file…needs RealPlayer)
  8. Anti-Islamic claim:  The Seven Earths
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  9. Anti-Islamic claim:  Stars created to be thrown at devils?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Fariduddien Rice
  10. Anti-Islamic claim:  Sun and moon are subject to man?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Fariduddien Rice
  11. Anti-Islamic claim:  Mountains and Earthquakes
    Islamic Responses:  My responseA Muslim ResponseJamal Badawi’s debate with Anis Sorrosh

    Claim used to exist on their site, but they later on silently removed it.
    Anti-Islamic claim: Orbits of Earth, Moon, & Sun  (Site doesn’t exist)
    Islamic Responses: My response and detailed rebuttal to a similar articleResponse by brother Frank
  12. Anti-Islamic claim:  The impossible conversation
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  13. Anti-Islamic claim:  Solomon and the animals
    Islamic Responses:  
    My response
  14. Anti-Islamic claim:  Shaking the trunk of the palm tree?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  15. Anti-Islamic claim:  Thinking with the breasts
    Islamic Responses:  
    My response
    Response by Shaahin Amiri-Sharif
  16. Anti-Islamic claim:  All things are made in pairs?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
    A response by brother John Wuurt
    My response
  17. History:Anti-Islamic claim:  The Qur’an Attacks … Christianity?
    Islamic Responses:My responses regarding “Son of God”:


    1. The Bible directly claims that ANY “Son of GOD” is a “God”! (Refutation to Jesus’ being God meaning that he is GOD Almighty).
    2. The definition of “Son of God” in Islam.
    3. Son of GOD: Some Muslims’ Misconception.
    4. “Son of Man” does not mean “GOD” or “Son of GOD”
    5. “Son of God” literally means “Servant of God” in Hebrew.  Bible agrees with Islam, not with pagan trinity and today’s wrong and twisted translations of “Son of God”.

    My response   (regarding GOD Almighty having wives……..see the “Holy Family Trinity”)

    Response by Islamic Awareness  (regarding GOD Almighty having wives)

    My response  (regarding Ezra)

    Response by Islamic Awareness  (regarding Ezra)

  18. Anti-Islamic claim:  Moses and the Samaritan?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by Matthew Smith (Yusuf)Samaritan error?
  19. Anti-Islamic claim:  The farthest Mosque?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic AwarenessMy response
  20. Anti-Islamic claim:  Alexander the Great, a Muslim?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
    A Muslim’s Response
    Another Muslim Response
    Another Muslim Response
  21. Anti-Islamic claim: None else was named “John” before John the Baptist?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    My response
  22. Anti-Islamic claim:  Two Pharaohs who crucified?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by Khalid Jan
  23. Anti-Islamic claim:  Burnt bricks in Egypt?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
  24. Anti-Islamic claim:  Were they utterly destroyed?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  25. Anti-Islamic claim:  Jesus was not crucified?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  26. Anti-Islamic claim:  The anachronistic title al-`Aziz given to Potiphar
    Islamic Responses:   Response by Islamic Awareness

The Quran in Contradiction to the Earlier Revelations:

Historical Compressions:

  1. Anti-Islamic claim:  Saul, David, Gideon and Goliath
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  2. Anti-Islamic claim:  A Samaritan tempting the Israelites in Moses time?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    My response
    Response by Matthew Smith (Yusuf).
  3. Anti-Islamic claim:  Prophets and Kings in Israel before the time of Moses?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  4. Anti-Islamic claim:  Moses and the Gospel?
    Islamic Responses: Muslim Response
  5. Anti-Islamic claim:  Punishment for future disobedience?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  6. Anti-Islamic claim:  Mary, the sister of Aaron (Harun or Haroon in Arabic)?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    My response
    Response by Abdul Haleem.
  7. Anti-Islamic claim:  Pharaoh and Haman?
    Islamic Responses: Historical Errors Of The Qur’an: Pharaoh & Haman?
    Were Burnt Bricks Used In Ancient Egypt In The Time of Moses(P)?
    Response by Matthew Smith (Yusuf)
    Response by Samer Kadoura.
    My response
  8. Anti-Islamic claim:  Abraham’s name
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  9. Anti-Islamic claim:  Abraham and Solomon
    Islamic Responses: My response
  10. Other contradictions in comparison to the Bible:
    Introductory remark
    Muslim Response
  11. Anti-Islamic claim:  Did God teach Adam the names of the animals?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  12. Anti-Islamic claim:  Were Believers Really Called Muslims Before the Time of Muhammad?
    Islamic Responses:  My response. (1)
    My response. (2) [Jesus used the word “Muslim” in Luke 6:4]
  13. Anti-Islamic claim:  The Quran’s Mistakes regarding the Biblical Patriarchs
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  14. Anti-Islamic claim:  Who Adopted Moses: Pharaoh’s Daughter or Pharaoh’s Wife?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  15. Anti-Islamic claim:  A Flood in the time of Moses?
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  16. Anti-Islamic claim:  The Quran, Moses and the Tablets of Stone.
    Islamic Responses:  My response.
  17. Anti-Islamic claim:  Solomon Working with Demons
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Umar.
    My response.
  18. Anti-Islamic claim:  Israel’s Response to the Covenant: ‘We Obey’ or ‘We Disobey’?
    Islamic Responses:  My responseResponse by MENJ
  19. Anti-Islamic claim:  Where is the Blood?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
  20. Anti-Islamic claim:  Animal sacrifices for Christians?
    Islamic Responses: My response
  21. Anti-Islamic claim:  How many messengers at Noah’s time?
    Islamic Responses: My response
  22. Anti-Islamic claim:  Why did the Queen of Sheba come to Solomon?
    Islamic Responses: My response
  23. Anti-Islamic claim:  Ezra the Son of God?
    Islamic Responses:  Response by Islamic Awareness
    My response
    Response by Matthew Smith (Yusuf)
  24. Anti-Islamic claim:  Jesus reached old age?
    Islamic Responses: Response by Islamic Awareness
    Response by Karim
    My response
  25. Anti-Islamic claim:  Did the golden calf say ‘Moo’?
    Islamic Responses: My response
    Response by a Muslim.
  26. Anti-Islamic claim:  Did disobedience result in extra commandments?
    Islamic Responses: My response
  27. Anti-Islamic claim:  How many messengers were sent to Noah’s people?
    Islamic Responses: My response
  28. Anti-Islamic claim:  The Progeny of Abraham?
    Islamic Responses: My response
  29. Anti-Islamic claim:  Two young men?
    Islamic Responses:  My response
Advertisements